Who Dat? – M

It’s taken many of us several days to figure out what happened in Tuesday’s election — which has to rate as one of the most astounding results in presidential history.  So it may not be fair to now ask you to try and figure out who these “unknown” campaign buttons are for.

As our fellow political junkies know, for some time now we’ve been showing photos of unknown buttons, arranged alphabetically by candidate names, for you to help identify.  We can’t make heads or tails of these candidates, most of whom we’ve never heard of.  And when we see a “Smith for Congress” or a “Jones for Senator” button, how do we know which Smith or which Jones?  So we’ve been posting pictures of these buttons, hoping you will have the answer.  Often, you have come through, which is most appreciated.

Thus far, we’ve completed the first 12 letters of the alphabet.  (Check out our previous “Who Dats”:  Unknowns beginning with the Letter A, Letter B, two pages for Letter C (here and here), Letter D, Letter E, Letter F, Letter G, Letter H, Letter I, Letter J, Letter K and Letter L.)  We even have one of buttons with pictures only — no names.  That’s even harder to decipher.

We now bring you to the Letter M.  Can anyone help with the identification of these buttons?  We sure have a lot of them.  Thanks!  (See bottom for some notes.)

who-dat-m1-001who-dat-m2-001who-dat-m3-001who-dat-m4-001

Some identifications and thoughts since these buttons were put up:

ROW 2 — Mendelsohn (button 5) may be Queens, N.Y., 1954.

ROW 4 — Second tab reads “Murrin for Congress.”

ROW 5 — Last picture button reads “McCray for Governor.”

ROW 9 — “For Congress/Labor Choice/Francis M. McInerney 13th District.”  May be from N.J.

ROW 10 — Right under the McInerney button is one that reads “National Vice President” with “Maddox” on a map of Iowa.

ROW 16 — Faded picture button reads “Mills for Mayor.”

ROW 20 — Jeanne McKalip may be from Illinois.

ROW 23 — “Chuck McIlhinney” is from Pennsylvania.  “Elect Moylan Judge” may be from Florida.  “Martel” has a N.H. address on the curl.

 

28 Responses

  1. Larry Brokofsky says:

    The McCray for governor item was used by Warren T. McCray, was from Indiana, and ran in the 1916 Democratic primary, and has the Republican nominee in 1920.

  2. Michael Treinen says:

    Row 22: “Republican Mills Lt Governor” is Iowan Max Milo Mills (1920-1998), who was an Iowa State Republican Senator who ran for Lt Governor in 1966.

    Row 16:”MIN Lt. Gov.” is Minnette Doderer (1923-2005), a Democrat who served in the Iowa House of Representatives and was the first woman to run for the Lt Governor position in 1970 (and once again in 1978).

    Both of these items are in my collection.

  3. Douglas Fisher says:

    Would “McCall” perhaps be H. Carl McCall, who was elected to the offices of New York State Senator and NYS Comptroller, prior to his 2002 run for Governor?

  4. Bruce Gerhardt says:

    Charles Mulcrone was from Mackinac County, Michigan (City Treasurer (D) of St. Ignace).

  5. Daniel Fox says:

    James R. McCartney was West Virginia Secretary of State, 1975-77. He was appointed by Gov. Arch Moore, vice Edgar “Hike” Heiskell, and was defeated in 1976 when he sought election in his own right. http://www.ourcampaigns.com/CandidateDetail.html?CandidateID=232909

  6. Daniel Fox says:

    “Mandich for Mayor” — likely Peter Mandich, Democrat, elected mayor of Gary, Indiana in 1951 and 1955, serving 1952-58; resigned in 1958 to run for Lake /county sheriff; indicted in 1962 on Federal tax charges, but acquitted.

  7. Daniel Fox says:

    “Republican Mills Lt. Governor” — Perhaps Max Milo Mills of Iowa. He ran for this office twice, winning the GOP primary in 1966 (but losing the general), and losing the primary in 1968 to future U.S. Senator Roger Jepsen.

  8. Daniel Fox says:

    “Elect Mucci Representative’ — In 1946, Col. Henry Mucci, a war hero who liberated a Japanese POW camp, was the Democratic nominee for U.S. Representative from Bridgeport, Conn. He lost to John Davis Lodge, the brother of Henry Cabot Lodge and a future Governor and Ambassador. (See Stephen Hess, America’s Political Dynasties: From Adams to Clinton, pp. 479-80.) Is this button old enough to be from 1946, though?

  9. Daniel Fox says:

    “Remember McGeachey for Congress” — State Rep. Hector McGeachey ran in the Democratic primary in North Carolina 7 in 1972, losing the runoff to Charlie Rose. See Barone, Ujifusa, and Matthews, The Almanac of American Politics 1974, at p. 755.

  10. Daniel Fox says:

    “McCuen Can Win in ’70 Congress 5th District” — W. Rex McCuen sought the GOP nomination in 1970 in Minnesota 5, but lost the convention endorsement to Dick Enroth. See Winona Daily News, 2/11/70 (https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/43573959/ ) and 5/4/70 (https://www.newspapers.com/newspage/43614629/ )

  11. Daniel Fox says:

    “Re-Elect Miller to Congress” (top row of page 1) — The picture looks to me like Clement W. Miller (D-CA), congressman 1959-62 and author of Member of the House: Letters of a Congressman, who died in a plane crash in 1962.

    For comparison purposes, you can see his photo here: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Clement_Woodnutt_Miller

  12. Daniel Fox says:

    “Elect Madonick to Congress” — Carl Madonick was the GOP nominee in New York 21 in 1958, losing to Herbert Zelenko. See Congressional Quarterly, Congressional Elections 1946-1996, p. 224.

    • Ken Rudin says:

      Daniel, every source I have says that the Republican who ran against Zelenko in 1958 was “Medonick” not “Madonick,” which is the button in question.

      • Daniel Fox says:

        Ken —

        I rechecked CQ Congressional Elections and it does have “Medonick.”

        But all contemporaneous New York Times references to the N.Y. 21 race refer to Zelenko’s opponent as “Madonick.” See especially “Madonick, Protege of Javits, Fighting Zelenko in 21st,” NYT, Oct. 31, 1958, p. 18. See also “Election Notice,” NYT, 10/28/58, p. 28; “Complete Vote for Governor and Senator; Results of State and Local Contests,” NYT, 11/6/58, p. 28. (A search for “Carl Medonick” yielded no hits.) See also New York Age, 8/16/58. https://www.newspapers.com/search/#lnd=1&query=%22carl+madonick%22+21st+district&dr_year=1958-1958

  13. Daniel Fox says:

    “Elect McMorrow Mayor” — John P. McMorrow, a member of the ?Boston /school /committee, ran for mayor in 1959, coming in last in a primary field of five. See Murray Levin, The Alienated Voter: Politics in Boston(1960), pp. 8-9 and 15.

    https://archive.org/stream/alienatedvoterpo00levi#page/8/mode/2up/search/mcmorrow

  14. Daniel Fox says:

    The red “McGee” button on p. 2 — I actually own one of these. I bought it at a flea market in Springfield, Ohio, which is near Dayton, and the dealer I got it from had a lot of Dayton/Montgomery County campaign buttons. For this reason, I believe the button is for James H. McGee, Dayton’s first black mayor, who served 1970-81.

  15. primeny711 says:

    Joe Maltese was Republican candidate in Staten Island. He later became a Judge. I believe the McDonald for Congress button is for George McDonald, who ran in Democratic Primaries for Congress in Manhattan in 1980 and 1988. He now runs The Doe Fund in NY and ran for Mayor in 2013

  16. Daniel Fox says:

    I can’t pin it down any further, but I think the “Jo” Malmsten button (page 4, row 3) is from a state legislative race in Hennepin County, Minnesota.

    1. A Mrs. Jo Malmsten lived in Minneapolis (see Life magazine, 5/20/57), which is in Hennepin County.

    2. Perusal of Minnesota Blue Books available to me shows that Hennepin County had a state representative district designated District 42B from 1975 to at least 2010. Mrs. Malmsten does not appear to have been on any primary or general election ballot during that period, but the button may have been used in an endorsement convention. (I’m told that in Minnesota politics, it was customary for a candidate not to contest the primary if he/she lost the convention endorsement. See, e.g., Barone et al., Almanac of American Politics 1980, p. 457.)

    I have not been able to determine Mrs. Malmsten’s party or the year she ran.

  17. Daniel Fox says:

    “Murrin for Congress” tab – Probably Pennsylvania 11, 1936 or 1938.

    James B. Murrin, a former mayor of Carbondale, PA, challenged incumbent Patrick J. Boland in the 1936 Democratic primary in Pennsylvania 11 (Scranton) with the endorsement of Father Coughlin’s organization. After losing, he ran as an independent on the ticket of the Royal Oak Party (the Pennsylvania name for the Coughlin-backed Union party). See Philadelphia Inquirer, “Primary Opponent Stands by Owens in Congress Race,” 5/10/36, pg. 20, and “Lemke Petitions Filed at Capitol,” 9/3/36, pg. 7 (available here: http://www.fultonhistory.com/fulton.html ).

    In 1938, Murrin returned to the Democratic primary to run against Boland again, but again he lost. See Pittsburgh Press, “Congressional Races in State,” 5/16/38, pg. 8. https://news.google.com/newspapers?nid=djft3U1LymYC&dat=19380516&printsec=frontpage&hl=en

  18. Daniel Fox says:

    “I’m a Merson Person” – Possibly Alan Merson? This antiwar, environmentalist candidate ended Wayne Aspinall’s congressional career by upsetting him in the Colorado 4 Democratic primary in 1972, He went on to lose the general to Republican James P. Johnson. See Barone, Ujifusa, and Matthews, The Almanac of American Politics 1974, pp. 160-161.

  19. Daniel Fox says:

    “Vote Macheras Senator” (p. 1, row 6) — George P. Macheras was a five-time unsuccessful candidate for Massachusetts state senator from the First Middlesex District (Lowell). In 1962, ’64, and ’66 he ran in the Democratic primary; in 1968 he ran as an Independent; in 1970 he was the Republican nominee.

  20. Larry Brokofsky says:

    Ken, Just sat down and went thru some of your mayor pins pictured on page 3 above. I think I can help you with a few of them.

    1. Moylan For Mayor: 1945 Hartford, Connecticut
    2. Migas for mayor; 1942 Democrat, East Chicago, Indiana
    3. Mandich for mayor: Peter Mandich, 1954 Democratic primary, Gary, Indiana
    4. McMorrow, for mayor: John P. McMorrow, 1959, Boston, Mass.
    5. McCracken for mayor: William J. McCracken, 1937, Oakland, California
    6. Moylan for mayor: Cornelius A. Moylan, 1945, Hartford, Connecticut.

  21. David Vandeviver says:

    page 3, row 3: Moylan is Charles E. Moylan, sr. who lost the 1935 Demo. primary in the Baltimore mayoral race, see photo @

    Baltimore’s Deaf Heritage
    – Page 121 – Google Books Result

    https://books.google.com/books?isbn=1439645590

  22. David Vandeviver says:

    page 4, row 1: Mutchler is George Howell Mutchler Demo. Warren Co. NJ clerk elected in 1910, 1915 and possibly 1920.

Leave a Reply