Illinois’ Pat Quinn, Once The ‘Most Unpopular Governor,’ Headed To Easy Renomination

Turnarounds in politics are not new.  Think Richard Nixon, after his 1962 defeat in California and his farewell news conference, only to be resurrected in 1968.  Or Bill Clinton, thought to be mortally wounded after being dogged by the Gennifer Flowers and Vietnam draft controversies, only to go on to defeat a sitting president in 1992.

But “astonishing” may be the word best applicable for Gov. Pat Quinn.

The Illinois Democrat is, in a sense, an accidental governor, reaching the post only after the impeachment, conviction and removal of Rod Blagojevich on corruption charges in January 2009 (see my NPR Political Junkie posts here and here).

Pat Quinn 001
Illinois’ Pat Quinn has had his share of victories and defeats in his long political career.

Even the fact that he was lieutenant governor was somewhat of a surprise; he had a history of losing elections — for state treasurer in 1986, secretary of state in 1994, U.S. Senate in 1996 (to Dick Durbin), and lt. gov. in 1998.  When he tried again, in 2002, for LG, he won the primary, and had the good fortune to wind up on the same ticket as Blagojevich.  The ticket won that year, and again in 2006.  The rest, as a grand jury would say, is history.

But his history was not supposed to last long.  State Attorney General Lisa Madigan was prepared to take him on in the 2010 Democratic primary but decided against it.  State Comptroller Dan Hynes (D) did challenge him and came within a whisker of beating him.  Quinn then went on to win a full term in November but only in a squeaker against a comparatively unknown, very conservative downstate senator by the name of Bill Brady.  Quinn won by 46.8-45.9%.

He survived, but things were still looking bleak.  The state had one of the highest unemployment rates in the nation.  There were severe pension problems, and his raising taxes didn’t seem to fix much.  About a year ago, Public Policy Polling, showing him with a 64% disapproval rating, called him the most unpopular governor in the country.  With polls showing her a certain winner against Quinn, Madigan was all but sure to get in the race this time.  And former White House Chief of Staff and Commerce Secretary Bill Daley, the brother and son of Chicago mayors, actually did get in.

Then, strange things began to happen.  Madigan said no again.  Daley withdrew from the race seven weeks after he got in.  Incredibly, by the time of the filing deadline, Quinn was being opposed in the March 18 Democratic primary by just one person, a political novice named Tio Hardiman, an anti-violence advocate.  Quinn has all but ignored him and refuses to debate before the primary.

Of course, there are reasons why Quinn has escaped serious primary opposition.  The state’s economic picture has improved somewhat since last year’s disastrous polling numbers.  He’s pushing to raise the Illinois minimum wage from $8.25 to $10 an hour, a popular position, against GOP opposition.  To be sure, many of the problems remain, including a still high unemployment rate.  Perhaps one reason for the lack of Dem candidates eager to get in the race is because they see it as a lost cause in the general election.  But for now, Pat Quinn is counting his lucky stars that he finds himself in the position he’s in today.  The question is whether that good luck will continue into November, where one of the Republicans seeking the nomination — Brady, state Sen. Kirk Dillard, state Treasurer Dan Rutherford or venture capitalist Bruce Rauner — will be waiting for him.

On the ballot.  Thirty-six gubernatorial contests are up in 2014.  Here are my early ratings:


SAFE REPUBLICAN (12):  Alabama (Robert Bentley), Alaska (Sean Parnell), Idaho (Butch Otter), Iowa (Terry Branstad), Kansas (Sam Brownback), Nebraska (open: Dave Heineman term limited), Nevada (Brian Sandoval), New Mexico (Susana Martinez), Oklahoma (Mary Fallin), South Dakota (Dennis Daugaard), Tennessee (Bill Haslam), Wyoming (Matt Mead).

LIKELY/LEANING REPUBLICAN (6):  Arizona (open: Jan Brewer term limited), Georgia (Nathan Deal), Michigan (Rick Snyder), Ohio (John Kasich), Texas (open: Rick Perry retiring), Wisconsin (Scott Walker).

TOSSUP (2): Florida (Rick Scott), South Carolina (Nikki Haley).

LIKELY/LEANING LOSSES (2)Maine (Paul LePage), Pennsylvania (Tom Corbett).


SAFE DEMOCRATIC (6)California (Jerry Brown), Hawaii (Neil Abercrombie), Maryland (open: Martin O’Malley term limited), New York (Andrew Cuomo), Oregon (John Kitzhaber), Vermont (Peter Shumlin).

LIKELY/LEANING DEMOCRATIC (6):  Colorado (John Hickenlooper), Connecticut (Dan Malloy), Massachusetts (open: Deval Patrick retiring), Minnesota (Mark Dayton), New Hampshire (Maggie Hassan), Rhode Island (open: Lincoln Chafee retiring).

TOSSUP (1) Illinois (Pat Quinn).

LIKELY/LEANING LOSSES (1)Arkansas (open: Mike Beebe term limited).

I acknowledge that GOP Govs. Snyder of Mich. and Kasich of Ohio are in serious battles this year.  But for now I rate them slightly ahead of their Democratic opposition.

Tweet tweet.  I post periodic political updates during the week — some serious, some not — on Twitter. You can follow me at @kenrudin.

Big news:  There is now a Political Junkie page on Facebook!

Political Junkie segments on the radioCheck out my schedule to see/hear where I’ll be yakking next.

And Don’t Forget ScuttleButtonScuttleButtonAmerica’s favorite waste-of-time button puzzle, is back, and can be found on this same website.  A randomly selected winner will get a, shall we say, “customized” Political Junkie button. And fear not, Political Junkie t-shirts are coming!


March 4 — Texas primary.

March 6-8 — Annual meeting of the Conservative Political Action Conference (CPAC), National Harbor, Md.

March 11 — Special election in Florida’s 13th CD to fill the seat left vacant by the October death of Rep. C.W. Bill Young (R).

March 18 — Illinois primary.

Mailing listSign up to receive a weekly e-mail alert about the column and ScuttleButton puzzle.

Lautenberg 001This Day In Political History:  Sen. Frank Lautenberg (D-N.J.), the Senate’s oldest member at age 89, announces he will not seek re-election in 2014.  He was first elected in 1982 and re-elected twice more before leaving voluntarily in 2000.  He came out of retirement in 2002 on behest of Democrats who needed a replacement because their incumbent, Robert Torricelli, whose ethics were under question, was dropping out of the race.  He won that year and again in 2008 (Feb. 14, 2013).  Lautenberg would die on June 3, less than four months later.

Got a question? Ask Ken Rudin:

2 thoughts on “Illinois’ Pat Quinn, Once The ‘Most Unpopular Governor,’ Headed To Easy Renomination”

  1. Ken,
    On Pat Quinn -do you think the voters of Illinois knew who they were voting for, or his name was so familiar that they went into auto-pilot (which is what I do by the time I get to county coroner)?


Leave a Reply

Item added to cart.
0 items - $0.00